Here’s a recap of what came out of gatherings of the WTO’s General Council and its Dispute Settlement Body:
·
Dispute settlement reform
was unresolved and there was a pledge to continue talking next year
·
On the second fisheries
agreement, India and Indonesia were granted more time to air their concerns.
“Fish 2” was at the decision stage but was demoted to a “discussion” item
·
India, South Africa and
Turkey blocked a deal known as Investment Facilitation for Development.
That left it short of the needed consensus, even though 126 members backed its
incorporation into WTO bylaws
·
Progress was made on two
administrative issues: picking dates for the next ministerial conference (March
26-29, 2026, in Cameroon) and approval of WTO Secretariat pension reforms
Newly re-appointed Director General Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala
tried to maintain a positive outlook, saying she hopes members return in
the new year with a “spirit of compromise, ready to do deals.”
For an
organization that needs everyone to agree, that’s going to be a challenge when
US President-elect Donald Trump takes office January 20, 2025. His threatened
tariffs and “America First” trade agenda run counter to the mission of the
Geneva based WTO.
Trump promised 60% duties on Chinese imports and
at least 10% for the rest of the world. In November, he threatened to impose
further 10% tariffs on Beijing and 25% on Mexico and Canada if they fail to
stop the flow of fentanyl and undocumented migrants to the US.
All of
that violates the commitments that more than 160 nations make to join the WTO,
said Bill Reinsch, a Commerce Department official during the Clinton
administration and now a senior adviser at the Center for Strategic and
International Studies.
Trump is known to dislike multilateral institutions, having
withdrawn the US from a trade deal for the Indo-Pacific, the Paris Climate
Agreement and the World Health Organization in his first term.
He could quit the WTO, too. Or he could stay in it, heap
more scorn on the rules-based international order and ignore other countries
complaining about Washington’s protectionism.
In Trump’s first term, US Trade Representative Robert
Lighthizer watched the WTO’s appellate body grind to a standstill by
preventing the appointment of new judges as terms expired, leaving it short of
the number needed to function.
This
week Biden administration delegates blocked a move by 130 WTO member countries
that called for a restart of the process to fill vacancies on the appellate
body — the 82nd time that that proposal failed.
The outlook for the WTO to free itself of paralysis under
the incoming Trump administration isn’t favorable.
Jamieson Greer, Trump’s nominee for USTR, was a close
adviser to Lighthizer. His views on WTO relevancy are unclear, but he did say
in testimony in May that “efforts to hold China accountable under WTO
dispute mechanisms were largely unfruitful.”
The WTO also irked some Trump allies by accelerating
the process this year of approving Okonjo-Iweala for another four-year
term at its helm.
That was “almost certainly designed to prevent the incoming
Trump administration from having a say in the matter,” said Dennis Shea,
Trump’s ambassador to the WTO in his first term.
“The WTO already has diminished reputation in the United
States,” he said. “This unprecedented action only diminishes it further.”
According to a Geneva-based trade source, Trump’s name wasn’t mentioned during this week’s General Council session.
Courtesy: Bloomberg