Selling by foreigners keeps Pakistan stock market under pressure

During the week ended 15^th April benchmark of Pakistan Stock Exchange PSX-100 Index lost its winning streak in the last two sessions. The market closed at 33,767 levels, losing 201 points or down by 0.59%WoW. Strong earnings of refineries and Oil & Gas failed to counter negativity arising from political noise. Turnover once again plunged, with average daily traded volume declining to 190 million shares from 275 million, down by almost 31%WoW.

Key news flows during the week included: 1) Vitol Dubai completed acquisition of around 18 million or 15% of voting shares of HASCOL, 2) joint session of parliament passed "The Pakistan International Airlines Corporation (Conversion) Bill" to convert the national flag carrier into a public limited company, 3) Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif laid foundation stone of two power plants of 660MW in Thar as Sindh provincial government reached financial close of 660MW Thar Coal Power Project, 4) companies from China' western region of Xinjiang signed deals worth US$2 billion, 5) Ministry of Water & Power recommended the GoP to withdraw 3% increase in GST on HSFO being consumed by IPPs, 6) Fauji Foundation expressed interest in purchasing 10% shares of MARI and, 7) Fitch Ratings affirmed Pakistan at 'B' with stable outlook.

Performance leaders during the week were: POL, SNGP, UBL, NCL and AGTL; while laggards included: DAWH, EPCL, PTC, FATIMA and LOTCHEM. Volume leaders were: TRG, BYCO, JSCL, DCL and DCH. Foreign participation failed to sustain last week’s trend where net outflows during the week amounted to US$1.46 million as compared to net inflows of US$27.7 million a week ago.

Led by healthy gains in energy and agricultural crop prices, the global commodity index exhibited strong recovery during March'16, up 7%MoM. Fastest to recover, oil prices led the pack with WTI/Brent gaining 13.6%/7.7%MoM in anticipation of Doha meeting of oil producers for capping the output to contain prevailing glut. Recovery in urea and coal was a function of pick‐up in demand and tighter supply respectively. Barring dairy (FAO dairy index down 8.2%MoM), food‐commodities fared well too with sugar and vegetable oil indices gaining 17.1%MoM and 6.3%MoM respectively. While recovery has been steady in March'16, sustainability of the trend depends on 1) improvement in demand and 2) containment of commodity oversupply. Until then, analysts expect commodity prices to continue to remain weak.

Automotive sales/production was recorded at 17,587/17,424 units in March’16, growing 11%/27%MoM, but down 17%/17%YoY, largely in line with expectation of post‐Rozgar scheme tapered growth scenario. Cumulative, 9MFY16 sales/production remained robust, resting at 166,898/167,217 units increasing 35%/35%YoY, driven by hogher offtake from PSMC (100,663 units sold, rising 51%YoY) and INDU (47,504 units sold, rising 18%YoY). The 800cc and below 1000cc segment exhibited 49%YoY growth during 9MFY16 (53,715 units sold, led by Mehran and Bolan), followed by the 1000cc segment rising 34%YoY (18,609 units sold, mainly due to the increase in Cultus sales and the 1300cc and above segment increased by 17%YoY (64,882 units sold with 20%YoY growth in Corolla sales). LCV sales outpaced the passenger car segment, where 9MFY16 sales were recorded at 29,692 units, an increase of 62%YoY, accentuated by Rozgar scheme driven offtake. Analysts remain bullish on local OEMs as new entrants remain few and far.

FCCL is scheduled to announce its 3QFY16 results on 18^th April’16. Analysts forecast the company to post net profit of Rs1.41 billion (EPS: Rs1.02) during 3QFY16, up 44%YoY. They expect this improvement in earnings to emanate from: 1) stellar growth in topline (+13%YoY to Rs5.01 billion) backed by 17%YoY increase in dispatches and 2) flatter cost of sales. In this regard, the low cost is likely to result from lower energy costs (average coal price down by 23%YoY), employment of 10MW WHR that came online towards the end of FY15 and cheaper in‐house power generation. As a result, Gross Margins are expected to go up by an impressive quantum to 44.35% in 3QFY16 from 36.74% in 3QFY15. Bottomline is expected to be further bolstered by decline in finance cost by 44%YoY owing to long‐term debt repayments. On a cumulative basis, analysts expect 9MFY16 earnings to grow to Rs4.19 billion (EPS: Rs3.04) compared to Rs2.65 billion (EPS: Rs1.92) for 9MFY15, up 58%YoY. Despite robust returns, analysts believe FCCL is still an interesting investment proposition due to its combination of growth and value characteristics.

Contrary to the expectations, State bank of Pakistan chose to keep policy rate unchanged at 6.0%, prompted by concerns on: 1) reversal in inflationary trends and 2) declining exports and increasing non‐oil imports making the current account more vulnerable to oil price shocks. That said, positive macro trends following earlier monetary easing were also highlighted with uptick in private sector credit and LSM growth at 4.1%YoY during 7MFY16 being notable improvements. Going forward, inflation is expected to accelerate as food prices pick up near Ramadan/Eid season. FY16 CPI inflation average is projected at 3.0%YoY while NFNE Core inflation is expected to average 4.2%YoY. Under the prevailing conditions analysts do not see room for further easing where probability for a modest hike before CY16 end due to external side risks, primarily: 1) chronic exports decline, 2) exchange rate volatility and 3) possible decline in foreign exchange reserves of the country.

Is pre Doha meeting oil rally sustainable?

On Tuesday oil breached US$43 a barrel. Brent was up 50 cents at $43.33 a barrel at 0842 GMT and earlier in the session reached a 2016 high of $43.53. WTI gained 39 cents to $40.75 a barrel.

The price movement is being attributed to the hopes being attached to an upcoming meeting of oil producers. The overwhelming perception is that the producers will agree on the measures to tackle the prevailing glut. The perception is also supported by a weak U.S. dollar and further signs of improving oil demand in China.

Many members of OPEC plus outside producers such as Russia are meeting in Doha, Qatar, on Sunday to discuss freezing output. However, two of the largest oil producing countries i.e. the US and Iran will not be taking any part in the deliberations.

As I have in my previous blogs the three largest oil producers/exporters Saudi Arabia, United States and Russia are not willing to contain output. They are insisting that Iran must also freeze output at January 2016 level. The logic is totally illogical.

In fact all the oil producing countries have succeeded in increasing their output after the imposition of economic sanctions on Iran. Therefore, Iran’s point carries weight that let it first regain its lost share and only then it would be willing to talk about containing its output.

There are growing fears that the upcoming meeting will prove a non-event as the three largest oil producers/exporters will not be ready to relinquish their market share to Iran.

  

State Bank of Pakistan keeps interest rate unchanged

State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) chose to keep policy rate unchanged and the announcement came through a Press Release. The announcement was disappointing because the business community was expecting a reduction of 50 basis points, at least. This perception emerged after the recent decision of Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to cut the policy rate.

RBI decision was in line with the policy of many central banks around the world and also the US Fed which deferred increase in policy rate due to faltering domestic as well as global economy. All the central banks are curtailing policy rates to boost their economies. One completely fails to understand the logic behind not reducing the rate, especially after the constitution of a new Monetary Policy Board at the central bank.

According to the central bank all the key indicators hints towards improving state of the economy of the country. However, it also warns about the future challenges that include stagnant growth of exports, looming energy crisis and subdued GDP growth rate.

Earlier, many of economic analysts were shocked to read a statement of Finance Minster that the country no longer needs the help of International Monetary Fund (IMF). They could recall a report on Bloomberg that Pakistan was inching towards default due to non-sustainability of its debt servicing obligations.

It may be true that he was upset due to inclusion of the names of sons of Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif in the list of Panama Leaks. But no one expected that he could go insane and say that Pakistan does not need the IMF.

Next General Elections are due in 2018 and it was expected that the incumbent would prefer to maintain even more cordial relationship with the IMF but spending more money on developmental programs for boosting confidence of its vote bank.

Pakistan needs to boost its GDP growth rate and the IMF has rightly suggested focusing on improving supply side. This demands spending more on creation of productive facilities and improving capacity utilization of existing manufacturing facilities. Curtailing developmental expenditures is likely to further widening of ‘confidence deficit’ being faced by the PML government.

State Bank of Pakistan should reduce interest rate

State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) is scheduled to announce its Monetary Policy Statement on this Saturday (April 9th). While analysts are making all sorts of speculations certain quarters insist that SBP should reduce interest rate by 50 basis points at least. This demand is being raised after Reserve Bank of India (RBI) announced to cut the benchmark repurchase rate to 6.5 percent from 6.75 percent, the lowest since March 2011. This decision has been made despite many odds only to creating more room to face the upcoming challenges.

The options, in terms of priority, being talked about in Pakistan are: 1) maintaining status quo, 2) an increase and 3) a reduction. Some analysts fear that most probably the newly constituted Policy Board may opt for increasing the rate by bowing down before the IMF pressure. The effort will be to avoid any criticism by the lender of last resort, which is yet to release the last tranche. Keeping the IMF happy is most important because the incumbent government will have to enter into another agreement to meet its debt serving obligations.

To be honest I am fascinated by the decision of RBI chief of reducing the rate, though it may be termed notional. The logic being offered is simple, accelerating the GDP growth rate. He is not following any rocket science but the footsteps of many central banks, even the US Fed is not convinced about the interest rate hike.

The chief stated categorically that the stance of monetary policy would remain accommodative and RBI would continue to watch macroeconomic and financial developments with a view to respond with further policy action as space opens up. The present RBI chief has cut rate five times since January 2015. His option for further easing is limited due to the risk of a third straight year of below average rainfall.

It is true that pressure from the IMF is mounting on Pakistan for missing some key targets and the country may face even more stringent conditions under the new arrangements. However, the incumbent government has to come up with some home grown solutions rather than following IMF recipe blindly. This demands reduction in interest rate to facilitate fresh investment, creation of new jobs and above all improving Pakistan’s competitiveness in the global markets. The cost of doing business has to be brought down.

The cost of doing has to be brought down by reducing interest rate, bringing down electricity and gas tariffs and above all coming up with ‘business friendly policies’. The incumbent government has been enhancing tax on everything rather than catching tax evaders. Energy crisis is the outcome of blatant pilferage and non-payment of bills by certain groups.

Pakistan’s economy is plunging deeper into crisis and needs ‘out of box policies’. The focus must shift from collecting revenue to creation of new production facilities and jobs. Following the IMF recipe will not bring the country out of vicious circle of borrowing. The pace of economic activities has to be accelerated by bringing down cost of doing business and reduction in interest rate is the first step.