Darnomics or Illusion

Without mincing words, allow me to say that Pakistan’s Finance Minister, Ishaq Dar, is busy in creating illusion that with his taking rein of finance an era of prosperity has begun. His premise that Rupee has got stronger against US dollar is nothing but gimmickry.

Let me remind my readers around the world that lately US dollar was made stronger artificially by the US administration. The US also wanted to create illusion that hike in energy prices around the world has failed in denting economy of the country.

One may recall that lately when OPEC Plus decided to curtail output, Joe Biden, President, United States was most furious. He knows that hike in motor gasoline is bringing down his popularity graph, which may led to defeat of his party in the mid-term elections.

Therefore, the attempts by Dar to show that Rupee is getting stronger are ‘misplaced’. In this endeavor, Pakistan is bound to lose more of its limited foreign exchange reserves.

This is also to remind him that in Pakistan there is a huge mismatch between the inflow and outflow of dollars. IMF tranche may have provided a breather, but the quantum of debt servicing is grossly unmanageable.

The brutal fact is that the recent floods have devastated country’s agriculture, displaced millions of people and their rehabilitation requires millions of dollars. If I am right bulk of the aid has come in kind and whatever paltry amounts have come is ’peanuts’ only.

This is to also remind the Minister that higher interest rate and persistent hike in electricity and gas tariffs are rendering Pakistani manufacturers, particularly exporters of textiles and clothing, uncompetitive in the global markets.

It is writing on the wall that imports will go up and exports will come down, widening the current account deficit. Since Dar has no control over imports, Pakistan’s only savior could be exporters. However, the lust to collect more PDL to bridge budget deficit is killing golden-egg layer, textiles and clothing industry.

Although, I am not an admirer of Miftah Ismail, any attempt to portray Dar as savior is like building an empire on the dead body of another person. If the readers are unable to understand this narrative let me say, “Miftah was used to announce all the bad decisions and Dar is being projected as a Savior”.

To conclude allow me to say, “The incumbent government has no clue whatsoever regarding pulling the country out of current economic crisis, all its policies can be termed ‘firefighting’ but the fire is too big and water is too little.”

    

 

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Pakistan: Likely facets of Federal Budget FY23

Government of Pakistan (GoP) is scheduled to announce Federal Budget FY23 on June 10, 2022. Relations between International Monetary Fund (IMF) and Pakistan have not normalized despite change of Prime Minister. 

While it is anricipated that the upcoming budget will have measures that can ensure austerity and economic stability, the incumbent government is likely to opt for policies which can help the coalition remain in power over the next 18 months.

Budget outlay for FY23 is estimated at around Rs9.5 trillion as against budget of Rs8.5 trillion for FY22.

GoP is anticipated to set tax revenue collection target at Rs7.25 trillion for FY23, which will be 19% higher from the revised target of Rs6.1 trillion for FY22. It is likely to impose new taxation measures of about half a trillion in FY23 budget.

Current expenditure target is likely to be set at 12% of GDP for FY23 or Rs8 trillion which is around 11% YoY higher than what was budgeted for FY22.

Similarly, government is likely to set aside nearly Rs4 trillion for markup payment and Rs1.6 trillion for Defense expenditure.

Federal Public Sector Development (PSDP) is estimated at Rs800bn, as against Rs466 billion disbursed in 10MFY22 and revised budgeted of Rs603 billion for FY22.

Consolidated PSDP (Federal and Provincial) is anticipated at Rs1.4 trillion (1.8% of GDP) for FY23, as against Rs1.2 trillion for FY22.

A few taxation measures that are under consideration include: 1) increase in super tax for Banking sector and re-imposition of super tax on highly profitable companies, 2) increase in tax rate for individuals earning high salaries, 3) reduction in tax concessions and exemptions for various sectors, 4) increase in regulatory duties on luxury items, 5) luxury tax on immovable properties and vehicles,  and 6) increase in taxes for non-filers.

With the economic slowdown, tax revenue target of Rs7.25 trillion will be difficult to achieve for FY23. However, it will depend on the types and amounts of new taxes to be imposed in Budget FY23.

Upcoming budget is likely to be Neutral for Stock Market as we do not anticipate any change in Capital Gain Tax (CGT) rate of 12.5% and tax rate of 15% on dividend income. The budget is likely to be Neutral to Positive for sectors including Technology & Communication, Fertilizer, Insurance and Chemical Sectors. On other hand, it is likely to be Neutral to Negative for sectors including IPPs, Autos, Banks, Oil & Gas Exploration, Cement, Textile, OMCs, Tobacco, Steel and Pharmaceuticals.

Analysts believe that negatives relating to imposition of new taxes on listed companies are already priced in as valuations remain attractive. Market participants are keen to see the overall balance of payment situation and focus to remain on IMF and other foreign exchange inflows along with trend of international commodity prices. 

Pakistan market is currently trading at a discount. Analysts prefer sectors that offer high dividend yield, beneficiary of rising interest rates and currency depreciation.