Showing posts with label trust deficit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label trust deficit. Show all posts

Monday, 2 November 2026

Making Pakistan Economically Stronger

Pakistan faces three interconnected challenges: a trust deficit, a budget deficit and a trade deficit. These are not isolated economic problems; these reinforce one another. Weak investors’ confidence discourages productive investment, fiscal imbalances constrain development spending, and insufficient export competitiveness perpetuates external-sector pressures. The country must therefore adopt a coherent growth strategy that addresses these challenges at their roots rather than managing them through short-term measures.

Pakistan should target GDP growth above 5%, but achieving this objective requires more than setting ambitious targets. The government must create a business-friendly environment, formulate supportive policies and implement them consistently, in letter and spirit. Sustainable growth depends on productive investment, rising productivity, competitive exports and confidence in the continuity of economic policies.

Productivity and Competitiveness

Agriculture and manufacturing should be the principal engines of economic growth. The first priority must be to minimize wastage and create greater synergy across production, processing, storage, transportation and marketing. Competitiveness in international markets depends not simply on producing more, but on delivering quality products at competitive prices and within agreed timelines.

Agriculture requires modern farming techniques, quality seeds, efficient irrigation, mechanization, improved storage and stronger market linkages. Manufacturing needs modern machinery, skilled workers, quality certification, technological upgrading and greater value addition. Expanding production without addressing inefficiencies will only increase costs and weaken competitiveness.

The second priority is to raise production and productivity, while the third is to reduce the cost of production and doing business. Expensive energy, high financing costs, regulatory uncertainty, inefficient logistics and unpredictable taxation undermine the potential of domestic enterprises. The government must address these structural constraints instead of relying on temporary relief packages that rarely deliver lasting results.

Equally important is the need to stop the illegal influx of merchandise through smuggling, under-invoicing and other forms of trade evasion. These practices deprive the exchequer of revenue, undermine compliant businesses and discourage domestic investment. Effective border controls, transparent customs procedures and stronger enforcement must ensure a level playing field for local producers. Import substitution, however, should not become an excuse for protecting inefficient industries indefinitely.

Investment Foundation of Sustainable Growth

Higher production and productivity require fresh investment in capacity creation, balancing, replacement and modernization (BMR). Existing facilities must be upgraded, production bottlenecks removed and obsolete machinery replaced. New capacity should be developed where market demand, technological opportunities and export prospects justify investment.

Businesses cannot make long-term commitments when policies change unpredictably, regulations are applied inconsistently or the competitive environment favours selected interests. Rebuilding trust between the government and the private sector is therefore an economic imperative. Policy continuity, transparent decision-making and timely implementation are essential to encourage investors to commit their capital.

Pakistan must also develop a new financing culture in which businesses rely more on equity and less excessively on borrowing. The Pakistan Stock Exchange should become a major channel for mobilizing domestic savings and directing them towards productive enterprise. Companies should be encouraged to raise capital through public offerings, rights issues and other appropriate equity instruments.

Unlike debt, equity does not impose fixed interest payments or scheduled principal repayments. A deeper capital market can therefore support expansion, strengthen corporate balance sheets, broaden ownership and reduce dependence on bank financing. This requires better investor protection, stronger corporate governance and greater public confidence in the stock market.

Reward Formalization and Productive Enterprise

Companies perform three fundamental economic functions: they establish productive facilities, create employment opportunities and generate exportable surpluses. Listed companies can make an additional contribution by improving financial disclosure, strengthening corporate governance and bringing more economic activity into the documented sector.

Pakistan's tax policy should recognize these wider economic benefits. The government should consider a significant reduction in the corporate tax rate for listed companies, subject to a transparent and carefully designed framework. Such an incentive could encourage businesses to seek stock exchange listings, retain and reinvest earnings, expand productive capacity and operate within the formal economy.

This reform should be accompanied by a broader and more equitable tax base, effective enforcement and safeguards against tax avoidance. The objective must be to reward transparency and productive investment rather than create another concession for established business interests. A simpler, predictable tax regime would also improve the country's appeal to domestic and foreign investors.

Economic Stabilization to Transformation

Pakistan cannot resolve its three deficits independently. Higher productivity and competitive exports can strengthen foreign-exchange earnings, while a broader documented economy can improve revenue mobilization. Greater reliance on equity financing can support investment without creating equivalent debt-servicing obligations. Above all, consistent policies can rebuild the trust necessary for sustained private-sector participation.

The government must move beyond managing recurring crises and create conditions in which productive businesses can invest, innovate, compete and grow. The success of economic policy should be measured not by the number of incentives announced, but by investment mobilized, capacity modernized, jobs created, exports expanded and wastage reduced.

Making Pakistan economically stronger requires a fundamental shift in priorities: from consumption to production, from excessive borrowing to equity financing, from protection to competitiveness, and from policy uncertainty to trust. If the government supports these changes with consistency and determination, growth above 5% can become a credible milestone on the path towards a more productive, resilient and prosperous economy.

 

Friday, 6 September 2024

Pakistan's biggest problem: lack of good governance

The matter of grave concern is that Pakistan suffers from three deficits: 1) budget deficit, 2) trade deficit and 3) trust deficit. Though we have listed trust deficit on number three, may economic analysts term it ‘mother of all evils’. The public trust in the ruling regime is at the lowest ebb. That is the reason Pakistan’s GDP growth rate has been hovering around 3 percent for years.

According to the experts the GDP growth rate is low because new investment is scanty, balancing, modernization and replacements are virtually nonexistent. To be honest the existing units face declining capacity utilization, which is leading to closure of the productive facilities.

The ruling regime often take pride in saying, ‘Pakistan is one of the best performing market’. The reality is around 500 companies are listed at the local stock exchange and only a small number of new companies listed is the last one decade. Banks are thriving because of huge investment in the government securities, exploration and production companies make fortune due to high international prices of crude oil, fertilizer plants are working below optimum capacity utilization, country imports huge quantity of refined products because of dismal capacity utilization and the list can continue.

To overcome budget the government has imposed huge taxes on each and every product, including lifesaving drugs and food items. Imposition of petroleum development levy increases power generation cost as well as transportation and logistics cost. High electricity and gas tariff encourage theft, which is evident from ballooning circular debt.

Over the last three years no effort has been made to contain expenditures, which prompts the government to borrow more, to be honest the government borrows to pay off the debt.

To conclude the government is creating new entities, which promise bringing in huge investment. One fails to understand if the existing industries are closing, local entrepreneurs and educated people are leaving the country, why should foreigners select Pakistan as an investment destination? The rulers must remember actions talk louder than words.