Owing to the steep increase in gas and oil prices that
followed the outbreak of the war, Norway ultimately enjoyed a massive financial
windfall. In 2022 and 2023, it reaped nearly US$111 billion in additional
revenue from gas exports, according to recent estimates from the
finance ministry.
A question arises, why Norway was allocated a little more
than US$3.1 billion for support to Ukraine in its 2025 budget?
Combined with what it contributed in 2024, Norway’s support
for Ukraine amounts to less than 5 percent of its two-year war windfall. For
comparison, Germany, Europe’s largest single contributor, provided US$16.3
billion in military, financial, and humanitarian support for Ukraine from
January 2022 until the end of October 2024, and the United States has contributed
US$92 billion. But while Norway’s two-year windfall is larger than the US and
German contributions combined, Norway’s support for Ukraine as a share of GDP,
at 0.7 percent, ranks only ninth in Europe, far behind Denmark (2 percent) and
Estonia (2.2 percent).
Not only does Norway have the capacity to be making far more
of a difference to the outcome of the war and the subsequent civilian
reconstruction; it has an obvious moral obligation to do so. Given that its
excess revenues are a direct consequence of Russia’s war, surely a greater
share of them should go to those fighting and dying on the front lines to keep
their country free.
Instead, Norway’s government has effectively decided to be a
war profiteer, clinging greedily to its lucky gains. To their credit,
opposition parties have proposed higher levels of support for Ukraine,
ultimately pushing up the sum that the government initially proposed. No party,
however, has come anywhere close to suggesting a transfer of the total war
windfall to Ukraine.
The
Norwegian government’s position is puzzling, given that Norway shares a border
with Russia and has long relied on its allies’ support for its defense. Its own
national security would be jeopardized if Russia wins the war or is militarily
emboldened by a peace agreement skewed in its favor.
Moreover, it is not as though Norway would be immiserated by
transferring its war windfall to Ukraine. This windfall represents about 6
percent of its sovereign wealth fund, the world’s largest, with assets valued at
US$1.7 trillion—or US$308,000 for every Norwegian.
True, Norway channels all government revenue from oil and
gas production to its sovereign wealth fund, and no more than 3 percent of the
value of the fund can be drawn down and transferred to the government budget
each year. This rule helps limit the effects on inflation and the exchange
rate, and ensures that the fund exists in perpetuity.
But as a macroeconomic and national savings instrument, the
drawdown rule was not designed with wartime demands in mind. It therefore
should not be seen as an obstacle for a larger transfer to Ukraine. Since such
a transfer would not enter the Norwegian economy, it would have no domestic
inflationary or other macroeconomic implications. (With the 2025 budget largely
set, it would need to be an extrabudgetary measure justified by the wartime
circumstances.)
This is
not the first time that Norway’s hoarding of its war windfall has been an
issue. But it is the first time that we have been given an official estimate of
the windfall’s value.
The finance ministry has assigned a number to natural-gas
export revenues in excess of what they would have been had gas prices remained
around their five-year pre-invasion average. Although such counterfactuals will
always be subject to uncertainty and debate, the official estimate is the
closest we will get to a value for Norway’s war windfall.
In fact, the actual number is probably much higher, as the
estimate does not include excess revenues resulting from higher oil prices
following the invasion.
With Europeans wringing their hands about the implications
of Donald Trump’s return to power, Norway’s government and parliament should
transfer the windfall to Ukraine in the form of military and financial support.
Norway has a powerful national-security interest in doing the right thing.
No comments:
Post a Comment