While some parties have developed a genuine popular
following, other projects have fizzled out rather quickly. Three king’s parties
suffered the latter fate in last week’s elections.
The Istehkam-i-Pakistan Party (IPP), constructed by
assembling PTI deserters, was being touted as the next big thing, particularly
in Punjab. Yet this prediction failed spectacularly as it managed
only two National Assembly seats, also putting in a dismal performance in
Punjab. Chastened by the rout, IPP supremo Jahangir Tareen retired from
politics. One wonders if the IPP will survive till the next election cycle.
The PTI-Parliamentarians did worse, winning no NA seats,
while the Balochistan Awami Party, created by the powers that be in 2018 and
comprising mostly ex-PML-N members, was also humbled in the polls.
As mentioned, cobbling together king’s parties is not a new
phenomenon. For the longest time, the name of the Muslim League — Pakistan’s
grand old party — was used by military strongmen, including generals Ayub Khan
and Zia, to form parties that could give their projects a civilian face.
Gen Musharraf patronised the PML-Q in 2002,
carving it out of PML. But whereas the party of the Sharifs has survived, the
Q-League is not a potent political force. Today, there are countless factions
of the Muslim League, many of them the products of military rule, or one-man
parties. In other instances, electoral alliances were carved out to keep
popular parties in check, such as the Islami Jamhoori Ittehad in
1988.
Yet some parties have earned their democratic stripes,
despite being products of dictatorship. The PML-N is a prime example; Nawaz
Sharif began his political journey in the Zia era, but today, has a genuine
following. Other than parties custom-built by the gentlemen in Rawalpindi,
other political forces, while not being the king’s men, have served the purpose
at critical junctures.
The MQM is one example, as it has done the bidding of the
establishment at various times, and been rewarded with ‘heavy’ mandates in
Karachi.
The PPP also played ball with the powers, particularly in
the turbulent 1990s. These alliances with unelected forces — while serving the
short-term interests of these parties — have done long-term harm to Pakistani
democracy.
The only way to stave off the continuous crises that afflict
Pakistani politics is for powerful quarters to stop creating and patronising
political parties, and to let representatives genuinely elected by the people
chart the future course of this country.
Inorganic creations have short shelf-lives and limited
appeal, and despite widespread manipulation of the system, are rejected by
voters. Only those political forces thrive that either turn away from their
creators, or look only to the people for legitimacy.
Dawn Editorial Dated February 16, 2024
No comments:
Post a Comment